Lame-ass Press & Malaysia's Chief Editor-in-Chief
Who says there isn't such a post -- Malaysia's Chief Editor-in-Chief?
Malaysiakini reported that editors had been told not to put the Bar Council's MARCH FOR JUSTICE news in the front page, back page or in the earlier editions.
However, the editors were also told that they could run the march stories from page four onwards.
An editor of a vernacular press has confirmed the instruction, Malaysiakini said.
Toe the line
Despite the promise of a freer media in Malaysia, what it now takes is just for the instruction to come through telephone calls from an unnamed officer at the Internal Security Ministry to reach the editors of the main dailies.
Evidently, all our Group Editors-in-Chief had toed the line, without fail, when the papers hit the streets today.
The Star, New Straits Times and Utusan Malaysia all carried the news on Page 4, while Berita Harian placed it on Page 5.
However, the lead story on NST is about ACA purportedly intended to record a statement from lawyer VK Lingam.
Centre-spread in Chinese Press
Interestingly, the Chinese Press had dedicated the centre-spread to give the march news maximum highlight -- Sin Chew on pages 17 and 18, with more news items flowing pages 20 and 21. Whereas, Nanyang Siang Pau on pages ran it on pages 12 and 13, and Guang Ming on its full-colour centre-spread.
Oriental Daily News ran it on pages 4 and 5.
Surprisingly, Tamil press Malaysia Nanban and Tamil Nesan both defied the instruction and ran the story on Page 2.
Makkal Osai, whose publishing permit was suspended for one month recently, obediently ran it on Page 4.
Sinar Harian, the East Coast originated Malaysia tabloid owned by Kumpulan Karangkraf that sees tiny-winy circulation, ran a march picture of substantial size on the front page of its Pahang and Klang Valley editions today (see picture left).
Never freer media?
More recently, newspapers were told not to publish any debates on two issues: ( 1 ) the polemic of Islamic state sparked off by DPM Najib Abd Razak; and ( 2 ) the Namee's Negaraku-ku video.
A bureaucrat by the name of Che Din Yusof had gone on record by saying that the two issues could only be published as news if they contained comments from the prime minister or his deputy.
I am pleased to announce that the ministry is helmed by none other than Abdullah Badawi and his two deputies, FAK and Johari Baharum.
For the record, when Anwar Ibrahim first exposed the Lingam Tape om September 19, all the mainstream media self-muzzled by reporting the most skimpy of journalistic details, though their reporters were shown the video in the same format it was submitted as evidence to the Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA).
There's never been a freer media in Malaysia?
Comments
tell me about!
World Bank says: "World bank Votes Singapore Best Country for Business"
Bernama says: "Malaysia Among 25 Most Business-friendly Economies" (Malaysia is no.24!!!!)
IHT says, "Too Business-Friendly in Hong Kong and Malaysia"
ha ha ha... (http://www.iht.com/articles/1998/12/31/edbow.t_2.php)
Posted by: regularguy
|
September 27, 2007 03:51 PM
Folks
It confirms that this UMNO-led Govt is a Fascist Govt.
It is worse than a police state.
Malaysia has been turned surreptitiously into a FASCIST STATE.
Read here the 14 Characteristics of a FASCIST STATE:
http://www.rense.com/general37/fascism.htm
Malaysia met 12 of the 14 Characteristics.
Update yourself what is fascism:
(a) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism
(b) http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/mussolini-fascism.html
(c) http://www.econlib.org/LIBRARY/Enc/Fascism.html
Posted by: Frank&Honest
|
September 27, 2007 03:56 PM
Political junta as well.
Posted by: Neil
|
September 27, 2007 04:04 PM
Frank&Honest,
I don't agree with you. From what I see now, Malaysia met 14 out of the 14 Characteristics.
Posted by: Steve
|
September 27, 2007 04:27 PM
Sinar Harian, the latest tabloid in town, owned by Kumpulan Karangkraf (Utusan group?), has the protest picture at the front page.
http://www.sinarharian.com.my/selangor/cover/cover.jpg
Posted by: howsy
|
September 27, 2007 04:27 PM
Wow... I never quite understood the meaning of left wing and right wing, let alone facism. How ironic that I've actually been living under a facist regime all this time! Now, I'm more convinced than ever that I should vote with my feet! It hurts to know that this once well loved country has been plundered, abused & manipulated to UMNO's own gain. I hope that one day, even their own children will despise them and dance on their grave for the evil that they are doing to the country today!
Posted by: ordinaryperson
|
September 27, 2007 04:43 PM
Get real people. The press in Malaysia has to self censor. Isn't it better that we do at least have newspapers and TV news broacasts than none, if they are closed down completely. The fact that some journalists 'moonlight' by putting the real stories our into cyberspace, at least means that they are still employed (a big plus, I think!) have access to the stories, and have the enthusiasm to make sure the story is still heard. It is when the press buckles down completely and is totally gagged, that we have to really worry. At least we still have the information to form opinions and make judgments.
Posted by: LLtwigs
|
September 28, 2007 06:43 AM
LLtwigs
Where have you been. In the cave or what.
Don't you know that the press is totally gagged inasfar as local news except for accidents, robberies and press statements from Ministers?
This Govt gagged the press to highlight the march, the shutdown on the PKFZ issue and others over the last 30 years.
Presumably you were born late to know this.
Posted by: Frank&Honest
|
September 28, 2007 05:20 PM
au contraire, Frank & Honest. I have been around for a good long while and I remember 1987 well. Please read my comments carefully. I am not saying I agree that they should have to be self censoring. I am indicating that they need to do this for self preservation. If you can at least keep your job, you still have access to the information, and with cyberspace there are many ways of getting this information out there, even if it doesn't have the same 'authenticity' as that given by the mainstream papers or TV news broadcasts. I have sufficient contacts with journalists to know that they and their media owners are watched VERY carefully, and it only takes a few minutes for a response to anything even a little bit 'sensitive', where there will be queries by one or other of the 'watchers'. Perhaps if we had had the opportunities we now have to 'get the story out there', in 1987 and 1969, we would perhaps now be better informed about those times.
Posted by: LLtwigs
|
September 29, 2007 08:16 AM
LLtwigs
Thanks for the clarification.
We need to distinguish between journalists/editors trying to put food on the table and having to play ball with the political masters owning the press.
Here, what we are concerned is that the press is OWNED by the UMNO and MCA. They are the govt.
I can only empathise with the journalists but the fact remains the press is NOT serving the public good and the national interest. I am not blaming the journalists/editors, but the owners of the press.
These journalists and editors, if they are worth their salt and if they hold dearly to the ethics of decent journalism if they are trained, would find jobs elsewhere.
But then again, other pro-UMNO and MCA journalists will join the fold.
Distinguish between journalist trying to earn a decent living and the institution called the Malaysian mainstream press.
Posted by: Frank&Honest
|
September 29, 2007 12:13 PM
Maybe the right way left is for our journalists to write the 'politically correct' stuff for their bread-n-butter in the mainstream media, AND write incognito the full truth as commentators and bloggers even in blogosphere. Some already are, one notes, but more should too.
They owe it to the rakyat who are choking in a fog of national inscrutability.
Right now, the Immigration Dept and its Home Ministry still have not come out with the real numbers on the number of people getting citizenship/mykads who are foreigners in Sabah and Sarawak.
Also the PKFZ fiasco has disappeared from the radar.
Not to forget the Lumut Shipyard Naval Boats contract.
The rakyat remember because blogosphere is a permanent record and constant reminder.
We have to do what is right once and for all. Really, enough is enough.
Posted by: Neil
|
September 29, 2007 08:08 PM