« Internet governance: Even Indonesia looks down on us | Main | Born-again writers »

Chun Wai: Embrace bloggers to avoid Ku Nan bloopers

Wong Chun Wai, the first mainstream editor who referred to Indonesian blogger Nila Tanzil's criticism on Tourism Malaysia to define our way of media handling and public governance, speaks on the same issue again in his Sunday column today.

He gives a friendly reminder to Tourism Ministry concerned in particular, and to the Government in general, on the many ways to skin a cat.

Referring to Ku Nan's video-taped press conference last week, in which blogger Rocky attended as a witness, Chun Wai says it was not a very clever thing for Ku Nan to do what he just did.

Last week, Ku Nan had tried to diffuse the controversy by clarifying that he did not mean all bloggers are liars, but by singling out Nila Tanzil as a liar. I didn't invent this. It's in the video-clip on Malaysiakini.tv.

It is not very clever, according to Chun Wai, because "it’s hardly good public relations to call someone a liar in public".

My layman command of English tells me I should read "not very clever" to mean plain "stupid".

Embrace blogs for our own good

Reading in between the lines, I can sense Chun Wai's frustration with leaders and bureaucrats of this country -- who don't understand an iota about blogs, who feared bloggers and thus who started to demonise the entire blogosphere -- for being out dead out of date. Quote:

There is no need to take criticisms badly. Some of our politicians or bureaucrats seem incapable of handling such brickbats, preferring to hear things that they want to hear only. Instead of addressing the issues concerned, some have reacted negatively and with intolerance.

To suggest that bloggers have an anti-national agenda simply implies that some of us are still not logged into blogsphere.

Some have yet to see the importance of the New Media, assuming that bloggers are all political commentators, without understanding that many travel writers have embraced the new medium for their writing.

From food reviewers to motoring journalists, many have chosen blogging to gain a bigger audience to complement the print and electronic media that they work in.

It’s a new world but it is still not too late for some of our politicians and bureaucrats to check out blogsphere.

The whole Ku Nan blooper, as I read Chun Wai's column and borrow his words, "was another case of another Malaysian politician shooting himself in the foot, which all seem so familiar by now".

Answer the questions, straight

Yesterday, Screenshots reported that Nila had demanded Ku Nan to refer to her directly by pinpointing specifically the portions of her blog about Tourism Malaysia that deserved her being labelled a liar.

That said and to date, Ku Nan has not fully answered the questions that Nila had raised, Chun Wai says. Here are some of them:

1 ) Nila's main complaint was that she was told by an official that the Malaysia Tourism Board would need two weeks to fulfil her request for accreditation letters. True or false?

2 ) She said her guide assigned by Tourism Malaysia during her coverage of Floral Fest 2007 did not even allow her to film at Chinatown. True or false? (In the video, Ku Nan said Nila wanted to film IKEA, instead.)

3 ) Ku Nan's comments that bloggers are liars -- and that bloggers are framed in context as parties who could cause inter-racial killings in the country -- were reported by Sin Chew Daily and the minister has claimed he was misquoted. Sin Chew has not retracted or apologised for its report, so we can assume the daily is sticking to its report, says Chun Wai.

Will Ku Nan, whom Chun praises as "one of the most humble and approachable ministers" who is also known for his openness and press savvy -- apologise to Nila Tanzil, the jobeless women and bloggers at large for his being "not very clever" by saying what he said?

4 ) Chun Wai says Tourism Ministry director-general Mirza Mohamad has replied (to some of Nila's questions) but some of the issues remain unanswered. What are those issues unresolved?

In summary, Chun Wai says there is nothing wrong in making an apology to Nila, "who continued to promote Malaysia strongly in her programme despite her unhappiness".

Will Ku Nan and his boys in Jakarta do something clever without further delay?

Ku Nan should heed Chun Wai's advice and urgently get his boys to read bloggers who have been actively promoting Malaysia -- samples are in this blog and LensaMalaysia.com -- by blogging, for free, about Malaysian travelogues, Malaysian food and beverages, Malaysian cultures and Malaysian heritage... the list goes on.

Blogs have that width and depth in content, and they are flourishing if global trends are anything to go by. While some of our salaried writers may have a difficulty in differentiating rectum from opinion, there are Malaysian bloggers who actively share their thoughts about how to make Malaysia tick.

That will stick.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jeffooi.com/mt32/mt-tb.cgi/1420

Comments

greetings jeff

it is always unfortunate that whenever the minister / government is being put into the bad limelight, they would invariably counter it that critics are lying and etc.

our politicians' pedigree does not seem to be able to tell between being critical and being anti-government.

i pay my taxes / i oblige and follow the rule/law but why is it so difficult for tax-payers like me to provide feedback to the system but yet to be called anti-government / establishment ?

does the fact that when you chastise / discipline your child for being naughty / mischievous makes the guardian / parent / teacher being a sadist / violent ?

poor Nila Tanzil not only lost her good friend due the the tragic air crash but has to be labeled/brandished being a liar for raising the above issues.

Jeff ,
Ku Nan’s off the cuff remarks and loose comments got him into trouble and you will find most main stream media ignore these types of comments to waste their valuable column-space. It is only the vernacular paper that highlighted them (sinchew). When things are technical, Samy can also get away with his comments as few bloggers and reporters are in the know to nail him.
But you missed the Malaysia Microchip launch Feb 24 2007 launch; you had a blog on this RFID chip way back in Sept 2003 when Dr M purchased the technology from Japan for an undisclosed sum
And this is what Home Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Radzi Sheikh Ahmad, was quoted in the STAR (Feb 25 07) after the launch by Abdullah
“The MM chip is highly acclaimed to be the world's smallest RFID chip with a built-in antenna and it can operate on three bands of radio frequencies”.
Malaysiakini believed it and had a headline “World’s Smallest Ready to Roll” On Feb 26 (but it was quickly taken down) and even AFP on Feb 27 screamed “Malaysia launches smallest microchip with radio technology” – all captured on jpg.
Who would challenge this until you google it? And you find the chip may be the smallest microchip - ONLY in Malaysia perhaps as in JAPAN, Hitachi's mu-chips (0.4mm x 0.4mm) are already in production and they had been used to prevent ticket forgery at last year's Aichi international technology exposition and they have developed even smaller ones (0.05mm x 0.05mm) POWDER TAGS (see pic) - 60 times smaller but NOT in production yet.
The spin was successful, as the respectable science PhysOrg.com carried the story and had it on their forum. All the above and more details from:
http://powerpresent.blogspot.com/2007/02/malaysia-launched-rfic-microchip-07mm-x.html
So bloggers can tell a lie from a spin.

The most diplomatic thing to do Ku Nan is to try and talk to SCTV Indonesia to reemploy NIla.

Otherwise, why don't you Torusim Malaysia in Jakarta to give her a job.

Its good and smart PR, Ku.

The big problem with the cabinet members is they can't see the wide-angle view. You have the parking lot abduction (local turned foreign), then the earsquat event (foreign turned local), then the demolition of a human being (foreign from afar), and now labelling a guest journalist (foreign from near) as a liar.

If the cabinet members could only see how the world has formed a poor opinion of this country from a series of concatenated events that happen to have common elements, they won't be so quick to shoot their mouths to mask their lack of brains.

The rest of the developing world has moved ahead; on a parallel event, what are we doing here witnessing a PM and deputy minister contradicting each other on who said what and who didn't? They sure know how to make this country which they presumably are trying to govern appear to be a madhouse.

On that score, what the tourism minister had said was as expected as one would expect what the s.i.l, the toupeeman, the silkygirl and all those others had said on other matters - the way bears the same motifs: fear, self-preservation, power-maintenance, blaming others (press, foreigners, women), craven denials and fact-twistings, and all sort of bully tactics only thugs and weak characters will adopt; never the straight candid answer.

Basically, they've lost it. That's because they're so lost. So that the first thing they should be doing is just hold a one-agenda meeting and ask each to answer honestly:

what's wrong with us the ministers (add: minions)?

There's nothing wrong with the rakyat who are increasingly finding better illumination and insight from bloggers.

One suspects the cabinet will miss the real message from the blogging phenomenon: it's all about transparency.

If governments are transparent about what they do, they will not have anything to worry about that's written. They seem to find it convenient for power-holding to use opaqueness as a tool to mount suppression on people who voice dissent on corruption, substandards, truth-hiding and incompetencies. They have such an arrogant and low opinion of the rakyat. That blogging is countering these with increasingly confident and influential coverage from day to day only shows the day for hiding truths is over.

Hiding truths will only deceive themselves in the end. When that happens, as we are seeing glimmers of it in the way the cabinet has been mis-conducting itself for so many years, it spells the end of what this country is all about.

neil, tired inside out.

Amen.
You sum it all up in half a page what we've been tossing around all week. And as always Neil, when you write, it's like someone drag a squeegy over the wet, stained and blurred windscreen.

Don't ever expect ANY of Bolehland ruling parties politickus to apology. It is not Bolehland cultures politickus to make apologies.

It will mean lost of face, and "not-macho" to those voters that vote them. No matter how insensitive speech the politickus made, as long as there is moron to support them, these politickus will never learn responsibilities.

At the end of the day, the job of Tourism Malaysia is a marketing tool for this country.

As a savvy marketer, the ministry should take seriously the criticism voiced by SCTV: apologise for the inconvenience or otherwise clarify the situation, and most importantly, make sure it does not happen again next year by giving a proper briefing, letters of accredition etc.

Something as simple as that would have cast Malaysia in a much better light. It's ok to make mistakes as we show ourselves willing to learn and improve.

INTERNET does not operate in a legal vacuum.
Read this before you post a comment in this blog!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)